How to estimate a stock’s fair price
A fair or “ceiling” price is the most it makes sense to pay for a stock, given what it delivers in earnings or dividends and the return you require. Buying below it gives you a margin of safety, Benjamin Graham’s central idea: if your projections are wrong, the low price cushions the mistake. Each method starts from a different assumption, so the calculator shows several side by side.
The main methods
| Method | Formula | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Graham number | √(22.5 × EPS × book value per share) | profitable, stable companies |
| Graham growth formula | EPS × (8.5 + 2 × growth) × 4.4 ÷ long-term bond yield | companies with moderate growth |
| Bazin | dividends per share ÷ minimum dividend yield | steady dividend payers |
| Gordon | next year’s dividend ÷ (required return − growth) | growing, predictable dividends |
| Peter Lynch | EPS × growth (P/E equal to growth) | growth companies |
Example
A fictional company with earnings per share (EPS) of $3.60, book value per share of $22 and $1.60 of dividends over the last 12 months:
- Graham number: √(22.5 × 3.60 × 22) = $42.21;
- Bazin with a 4% minimum yield: 1.60 ÷ 0.04 = $40.00;
- Gordon with a 9% required return and 3% dividend growth: 1.60 × 1.03 ÷ 0.06 = $27.47.
If the stock trades at $38, it is below the first two fair prices but above Gordon’s. The median of all methods that apply is a sensible single reference.
Watch out
- Use recurring earnings and dividends: one-off gains, such as the sale of a business unit, inflate EPS and every fair price.
- Cyclical companies (commodities, homebuilders) can look cheap at peak earnings. Prefer an average of several years.
- Bazin and Gordon do not work for companies that pay little in dividends; Graham and Lynch do not work with negative earnings.
- In the Gordon model, growth must be well below the required return, or the result explodes.
A fair price is a starting point for analysis, not a buy recommendation. Combine it with the quality of the business, its debt and the outlook for its industry.