Miles, points and cash back: what a mile is worth and when to buy
Miles and points are a currency with a floating value. To know whether to earn, buy or redeem them, the yardstick is the value per 1,000 miles, or cents per mile.
What a mile is worth on a redemption
Value per 1,000 = (cash fare − taxes and fees on the award) ÷ (miles ÷ 1,000). A $450 flight that costs 25,000 miles plus $11.20 gives $17.55 per 1,000 miles, about 1.76 cents per mile. That is the most it makes sense to pay for miles for that flight.
What a bought mile costs
Buying points at $25 per 1,000 with no bonus means the award would cost $636.20 (25 × $25 + $11.20), $186.20 more than paying cash. Buying miles only pays off during deep sales or for redemptions worth more per mile.
| How you pay | Cost | Savings |
|---|---|---|
| Cash | $450.00 | — |
| Miles bought ($25 per 1,000) + taxes | $636.20 | −$186.20 |
| Card miles + taxes (2% cash back given up) | $261.20 | $188.80 |
Points or cash back
A card earning 2 points per dollar, with miles worth 1.76 cents, returns 3.5% versus 2% on a cash back card. The $95 annual fee comes out of that: at $3,000 a month in spending, points earn $1,169 a year after the fee, against $720 in cash back.
Be careful
Miles expire, award charts change and transfer bonuses come and go. Buy miles only for a redemption you have already found, never spend more to earn points, and never carry a balance for rewards.